April 8, 2024
Brian Winterfeldt
Client Alert
Client Alert
Client Alert

From Catwalks to Courtrooms: Exploring the Hermes Birkin Handbag Controversy

External Article

This article is hosted away from the Winterfeldt website at

Anyone with a hint of style recognizes the iconic Hermes Birkin Bag - a symbol of prestige, elegance, craftsmanship, and reliability. Like a masterpiece by Claude Monet, some breeze by it, while others chase it across continents. Its sky-high value is partly due to Hermes' trademark protection, which has stirred some controversy as of late.

Whether bought retail or secondhand, the Birkin's allure lies in its impeccable construction and status symbol. Crafted from top-notch materials like calf, ostrich, lizard, and crocodile, each bag is hand-cut and stitched with precision. The blend of customization, attention to detail, and timeless style exudes unparalleled sophistication.

Yet, Hermes grapples with maintaining its brand's integrity amid counterfeit challenges, soaring demand for its limited-edition pieces, and the responsibility that comes with preserving a true work of art. In attempting to protect the essence of the Birkin bag, Hermes  finds itself entangled in a class action lawsuit, accusing them of exploiting and excluding select customers.

WIPG's Bryan Stanton interviews Carin Kirby, owner of Consign of the Times, to discuss the importance of brand protection for even secondary retailers, and how to work with companies like Hermes to keep bad actors out of the market

In our exploration of the Hermes Birkin bag's secondary market, we encounter a fascinating interplay between luxury, investment, and intellectual property law. As these iconic bags transition from retail to resale, the legal framework of trademark protection becomes increasingly relevant. Our journey into this realm is guided by Carin Kirby, the visionary founder of Consign of the Times, a pioneering luxury and designer resale boutique in Miami.

Consign of the Times, renowned for its exceptional value and impeccable customer service, epitomizes the evolution of luxury consignment. Through our conversation with Carin Kirby, we gain insights into the complexities surrounding the secondary market for Birkin bags. Despite their initial high prices, Birkin bags often appreciate in value during resale, a phenomenon driven by factors like scarcity, exclusivity, and the prestige associated with owning a Birkin.

Intellectual property law plays a crucial role in this market dynamic, particularly concerning trademark protection. The Birkin bag's iconic status is not just a result of its craftsmanship and allure but also the rigorous protection of its brand identity. Authentication processes further underscore the importance of trademark protection, ensuring that genuine Birkin bags maintain their value and integrity in a market flooded with counterfeit replicas.

Our exploration delves into how intellectual property laws and trademark protection intersect with the secondary market for Birkin bags, illuminating the legal and economic factors that contribute to their enduring appeal and escalating value.

Brian Winterfeldt, brian@winterfeldt.law, +1 202 903 4422

download this document as a PDF


* indicates required
/( mm / dd )